Homeownership comes with various responsibilities, one of the most significant being protecting your property and its systems. Two common ways to safeguard your home are home insurance and a home warranty plan. While they both provide protection, they serve different purposes and cover different aspects of homeownership. Below, we will explore what home insurance and home warranty plans are, how they differ, and what each covers.
Understanding Home Insurance: What It Covers

Home insurance protects your property and belongings from unexpected fires, theft, and natural disasters. It typically covers the structure of your home, personal belongings, and liability if someone is injured on your property. Most policies offer a broad range of protection for damage to the home and the homeowner's personal items.
In the event of significant damage, like a fire or severe weather, home insurance can help repair or rebuild your home. Additionally, it often covers the cost of temporary living arrangements if your home becomes uninhabitable. Liability coverage is another essential component, offering protection if someone is injured on your property and decides to file a lawsuit.
However, home insurance does not typically cover the day-to-day maintenance of your home or repairs to systems like your HVAC or plumbing. For these issues, homeowners must turn to other forms of protection, such as a home warranty. Reviewing your policy thoroughly to understand its limits is important, as exclusions can vary widely depending on the insurer.
One example of additional protection homeowners can consider is an AFC Home Warranty. These plans help with the cost of repairs or replacement for specific home systems and appliances that home insurance won't cover. With home insurance primarily focusing on catastrophic events, a home warranty fills in the gaps, particularly with home maintenance needs.
What a Home Warranty Plan Protects

A home warranty plan is designed to cover repairing or replacing home systems and appliances that fail due to normal wear and tear. These systems may include plumbing, electrical, and HVAC, while appliances could encompass refrigerators, ovens, and washing machines. Unlike home insurance, which addresses damage caused by accidents or disasters, home warranties are preventative and maintenance-focused.
When a covered appliance or system breaks down, a home warranty provider will send a technician to assess the issue and determine whether a repair or replacement is necessary. Homeowners typically pay a service call fee for the technician's visit, but the cost of the repair or replacement is covered under the warranty. This can significantly reduce the financial burden of unexpected repairs.
While a home warranty plan can provide peace of mind for many homeowners, it's important to note that not all issues are covered. Pre-existing conditions or poorly maintained systems may not be eligible for protection under the warranty. Reviewing the terms of a home warranty agreement is crucial to understanding its scope and limitations.
Key Differences Between Home Insurance and Home Warranty Plans
The most significant difference between home insurance and a home warranty plan is the type of protection they provide. Home insurance covers damage to the structure of your home and personal property caused by external events like natural disasters, theft, or vandalism. In contrast, a home warranty plan covers repairing or replacing home systems and appliances due to everyday wear and tear.
Another key difference is the cost structure. Home insurance policies tend to have higher premiums, especially in areas prone to natural disasters. These premiums are usually paid annually or monthly and may increase depending on the coverage and deductibles selected. In contrast, home warranty plans typically involve a lower upfront cost, often paid annually, and homeowners pay a service fee when repairs or replacements are needed.
The process for making claims also differs between the two. With home insurance, you typically file a claim for damage after an event occurs, and the insurer will evaluate the extent of the damage before reimbursing or covering the cost of repairs. Home warranty claims, however, are made when a home system or appliance breaks down and a technician is sent to handle the issue, often at no additional cost beyond the service fee.
Finally, the coverage scope differs greatly. Home insurance provides financial protection against major events that could destroy or damage your home, offering long-term security for many incidents. On the other hand, a home warranty plan serves as a form of preventive care, protecting against the failure of systems and appliances that homeowners rely on daily.
Altogether, home insurance and home warranty plans provide distinct forms of protection, each addressing different aspects of homeownership. While home insurance covers major damage and disasters, a home warranty plan focuses on repairing and replacing everyday systems and appliances.
Leave a Comment